Home > Asylum > Challenging the Legality of Child Detention

Challenging the Legality of Child Detention

By: Louise Smith, barrister - Updated: 27 Jan 2013 | comments*Discuss
 
Child Detention Uk Immigration Asylum

In May 2010 the UK’s new coalition government announced that they intended to end the detention of children in immigration removal centres (detention centres). In 2009 over 1000 children were detained in the UK for immigration purposes. Some of these children may have been living in the UK for years prior to their detention.

International Law on the Detention of Children

The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child states that children should not be:

  • “deprived of [their] liberty unlawfully or arbitrarily”; and that,
  • any detention should be a “last resort and for the shortest appropriate period of time.”
Many EU countries impose limits on detention for immigration purposes but seven do not. The UK is one of the seven which has no time limit. In Sweden, immigration administration centres are open - allowing people to come and go. The Swedish experience suggests that families rarely run away. Some EU states use methods such as electronic tagging of parents considered to be a high flight risk.

Children’s Commissioner and Concerns About Child Detention

Children seeking asylum in the UK may be amongst the most vulnerable individuals in our communities. England’s Children’s Commissioner from 2005 to 2010, Professor Sir Al Aynsley-Green, published a series of shaming reports on the plight of asylum-seeking children. He highlighted what he considered to be failings in the way that the UK Border Agency (UKBA) deals with children, and said that they should be afforded the same humanity and dignity that we would wish for our own children.

The Commissioner concluded that there appear to be significant discrepancies between policy and what actually happens to children during an arrest. Arrest teams were not complying with guidelines designed to minimise the distress and anxiety experienced by children. For example, during the arrest process, children were not given sufficient opportunity to collect their personal belongings.

The loss of personal possessions was found to be one of the most de-humanising aspects of the arrest process for both children and adults. Children detained at Yarl’s Wood told the Commissioner that it felt like a prison and expressed feelings of loss and anxiety about belongings, pets, the absence of contact with friends and the general change in routine. The Commissioner also raised concerns about the healthcare given to children in detention. He noted that some children with serious illnesses - or whose condition deteriorated in detention - were still detained.

Challenging Child Detention in the Courts

In November 2010 campaigners condemned the opening of a new detention centre in Croydon. Just six months after the government promised to end the detention of minors, the new Croydon centre is specifically designed to detain asylum seekers and their children. In another development that angered campaign groups, the UKBA began piloting a scheme to remove families from the UK without informing them of the date on which they will be arrested and put on a plane. Families would simply be informed that, after an initial grace period of 72 hours, they could be deported at any time during the next three weeks.

Campaign groups are now trying to challenge the legality of child detention in the High Court. They hope that, if child detention is ruled to be illegal, it could immediately be halted. The case has been brought on behalf of two single mothers and their children who were detained by UK Border Agency officers after dawn raids on their homes. A ruling is expected in January 2011.

The campaign groups have also lashed out at Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg for his perceived failure to follow through on promises to end child detention. Under pressure, Mr Clegg subsequently announced that child detention would end by May 2011. Clegg has reportedly struggled to overcome opposition to this change in policy from the UKBA and the Home Secretary, Theresa May. Immigration officials are believed to have voiced concerns that ending child detention could make it harder to achieve effective immigration control.

The detention of children will rarely be in their best interests and, when done for administrative purposes, must pose a serious threat to their human rights and welfare. The government announced in December 2010 that it intended to use alternative methods of monitoring children and families subject to immigration control. Whether child detention does end by May 2011 - or simply continues under another guise - remains to be seen.

You might also like...
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice..
Why not be the first to leave a comment for discussion, ask for advice or share your story...

If you'd like to ask a question one of our experts (workload permitting) or a helpful reader hopefully can help you... We also love comments and interesting stories

Title:
(never shown)
Firstname:
(never shown)
Surname:
(never shown)
Email:
(never shown)
Nickname:
(shown)
Comment:
Validate:
Enter word:
Latest Comments
  • Zeba
    Re: Giving Birth to a Child in the UK
    I've visited to U.K. With my husband and a one year child but I was pregnant when I visited and there accidentally I'd got…
    23 August 2017
  • Lek
    Re: Giving Birth to a Child in the UK
    My son he was born in the U.K. In 2014 but I have work permits visa. Question is how he get British citizenship or British…
    23 August 2017
  • Cheema
    Re: Marrying a UK Citizen
    Hi I am a British citizen and my partner is an Indian citizen who has overstayed his visa in the UK. We wish to get married soon, however…
    22 August 2017
  • Marta
    Re: Applying for UK Citizenship
    I've obtained a Permanent Residence document and would like to apply for a British Citizenship and Passport. I've lived in the UK…
    22 August 2017
  • Gulsah
    Re: Giving Birth to a Child in the UK
    Hello, My daughter was born 21st July 2017 and I have got my ILR on 8th August 2017. Is my daughter british citizen…
    22 August 2017
  • TeeJay
    Re: Life as a UK Citizen
    I am British married to an Italian 7 Years ago, living in Italy. We are both retired. If we wanted to return to the Uk, what are my husband's…
    22 August 2017
  • ana
    Re: Applying for UK Residency
    Hi, I have a few questions. Firstly, My boyfriend has a blue Belgian passport and he currently lives in Belgium. I am a British…
    22 August 2017
  • Zakiish
    Re: Applying for Visas for Extended Family
    Hello:my name is issack in kenya refugee ,my sister is u.k citizen and i would like to join her in u.k what is the…
    22 August 2017
  • AboutImmigration
    Re: Giving Birth to a Child in the UK
    Harry - Your Question:Myself and my wife are Indian citizens. My son was born and brought up in India and was a Indian…
    22 August 2017
  • rob
    Re: Registering a Child as a UK Citizen or National
    My daughter was born in 1980 in Botswana.Am British , mother Tswana. Daughter has Botswana passport. Was…
    22 August 2017
Further Reading...
Our Most Popular...
Add to my Yahoo!
Add to Google
Stumble this
Add to Twitter
Add To Facebook
RSS feed
You should seek independent professional advice before acting upon any information on the AboutImmigration website. Please read our Disclaimer.